Open Times
Monday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Tuesday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Wednesday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Thursday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Friday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Tucked along 210 Marble Ave in Pleasantville, Arthur Avenue feels like one of those places you stumble into once and immediately add to your regular rotation. The location itself is easy to miss if you’re just passing through, but locals clearly know what’s up-the steady stream of diners during lunch and early dinner hours says plenty about its reputation. From the moment you step inside, there’s a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere that leans more neighborhood favorite than polished fine dining, and that’s exactly part of its charm.
The menu leans heavily into Italian-American comfort food, with familiar staples done right rather than reinvented. You’ll find everything from hearty pasta dishes to classic chicken parm, and portions are generous without feeling over the top. On one visit, the penne alla vodka stood out with its balanced sauce-creamy without being too heavy, with just enough bite to keep it interesting. The pizza, too, deserves a mention: thin crust, crisp edges, and that slightly chewy center that makes each slice satisfying without feeling greasy. It’s the kind of place where you can confidently order something simple and still walk away impressed.
Service here matches the tone of the space-friendly, attentive, and refreshingly unpretentious. Staff members seem genuinely familiar with the menu and quick to offer suggestions if you’re undecided. During a busy dinner rush, there might be a short wait, but the turnover is steady, and the team handles the pace without making guests feel rushed. That balance is harder to achieve than it looks, and it adds to the overall comfort of dining here.
What really makes Arthur Avenue stand out among nearby restaurants is how it blends consistency with a sense of community. Online reviews often highlight the same points: reliable food quality, approachable pricing, and a warm, neighborhood vibe. It doesn’t try to be trendy or overly curated, which in today’s dining scene actually feels refreshing. Instead, it focuses on delivering a solid experience every time, whether you’re stopping by for a casual weeknight meal or meeting friends for a laid-back dinner.
While the menu doesn’t push boundaries or introduce experimental flavors, that’s not necessarily a drawback. If anything, it reinforces the restaurant’s identity as a dependable go-to spot. For anyone exploring Pleasantville’s dining options or just looking for a comfortable place with good food and easygoing energy, this spot quietly earns its place among the area’s most appreciated eateries.
2-cheese or pepperoni pizza,15 plain or buffalo wings, 12 housemate mozzarella sticks served w/tomato sauce
chicken cheese steak w/broccoli rabe, mozzarella & served w tomato sauce
CHIcken cutlet/mozzarella,prosciutto,arugala,roasted peppers& balsamic glaze or an Italian combo, salami,prosciutto,hot soppresatta,provolone,arugala,tomato& red wine vinaigrette both served w Italian potato salad no mayo
Chicken cutlet, broccoli rabe, cherry peppers, shaved asiago cheese and balsamic glaze
27 count.
Add grilled or breaded chicken for an additional charge.
Romaine lettuce, olives, tomatoes, cucumber, cheese and Italian cold cuts.
Monday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Tuesday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Wednesday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Thursday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Friday 02:30 PM - 08:00 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Contact Details
